The Strategy Library
Strategy No. 21

Paying Too Much for Risk the Business Rarely LosesCaptive Insurance, and Where Life Insurance Fits

A strategy for profitable businesses whose commercial insurance is expensive, full of exclusions, or missing entirely for risks the owner actually worries about: a captive is an insurance company the owners form to insure their own operating company's real risks, with premiums priced by an actuary and reserves held under regulatory oversight. Life insurance has a legitimate place around a captive, at the owner and succession level, and a problematic one inside it, and knowing the difference is the point of this entry.

Business & Succession
Last reviewed: October 2026
Who It's For

Owners of profitable, well‑run operating businesses, often with $20M or more in revenue, that carry significant uninsured or underinsured risks (high deductibles, exclusions, coverage that is unavailable or overpriced) and a track record of strong loss control.

Key Benefit

Coverage tailored to the risks the business really has, more control over claims and pricing, and the ability to retain underwriting profit inside an entity the owners own, when the captive operates as genuine insurance.

Trigger Question

Is this business paying for coverage that does not fit its risks, or carrying real risks that no commercial carrier will cover well, and would the owners run a captive as a real insurance company rather than as a tax strategy?

Watch first

Instructional video
Josh Sterling teaches this strategy
In this walkthrough, Josh teaches what separates a legitimate captive from the arrangements the IRS has targeted: the four tests for whether something is really insurance, how the Section 831(b) election works and why it draws scrutiny, the 2025 micro‑captive regulations and their loss ratio and financing tests, and why life insurance belongs at the owner and succession level rather than inside the captive's reserves.

The full picture

What it is

A captive insurance company is a licensed insurer owned by the business it insures (or by that business's owners). Instead of paying all premiums to commercial carriers, the operating company pays premiums to its captive for specific risks, often the ones commercial carriers price poorly or exclude: high deductibles, cyber, supply chain interruption, warranty, regulatory changes, loss of a key customer, and similar. The captive is regulated by the insurance department of its domicile, must be capitalized, and must price its policies using an independent actuary. If claims are lower than premiums over time, the underwriting profit stays in an entity the owners own, rather than with a commercial carrier.

For the premiums to be deductible insurance premiums, the arrangement must be insurance in the tax sense. Courts look for risk shifting (the risk moves from the operating company to the captive), risk distribution (the captive insures enough independent risks that the law of large numbers applies), insurance risk (genuine fortuitous risk, not investment or business risk), and conformity to commonly accepted notions of insurance (proper capitalization, arm's‑length pricing, valid policies, legitimate claims handling). A captive that fails these tests is not insurance, and its premiums are not deductible.

Many smaller captives elect under Section 831(b), which lets an insurer with premiums at or below an annual limit ($2.9M for 2026, indexed) be taxed only on its investment income, not on its underwriting income. Combined with the operating company's premium deduction, that creates a substantial tax incentive, which is precisely why this area has drawn intense enforcement. The IRS has won a series of Tax Court decisions, beginning with Avrahami v. Commissioner (2017), against arrangements that were priced to the tax benefit rather than to the risk. In January 2025, Treasury finalized regulations (T.D. 10029) that classify certain micro‑captive arrangements as listed transactions (generally, a loss ratio below 30% over the computation period combined with a "financing factor," meaning the captive's capital flows back to the insured or its owners without being taxed) and others as transactions of interest (including a loss ratio below 60%). Participants and their advisors have disclosure obligations, and penalties for failing to disclose are significant.

Where life insurance fits, and where it does not

The original version of this strategy described funding a captive "with life insurance." That framing needs care. Arrangements in which captive reserves are used to buy life insurance on the owners, or in which value moves back to the owners through policies, loans, or similar transfers, can look like the disguised return of capital that the financing factor targets, and they undermine the argument that the captive is a real insurer. Captive reserves should be invested like an insurer's reserves, conservatively and available to pay claims.

Life insurance has a legitimate and often important role around a captive:

  1. Estate liquidity for the captive interest. A successful captive accumulates value that is an estate asset of its owners. Life insurance held in an irrevocable trust can provide liquidity for estate taxes and equalization without forcing the captive to be liquidated or the operating company to be sold.
  2. Succession and buy‑sell funding. When a captive has several owners, or when the operating company's succession plan changes ownership, the captive's ownership needs to move with it. Buy‑sell funding at the owner level keeps those transitions orderly.
  3. Key person protection for the operating company. Loss of a principal is a business risk best handled with properly owned key person coverage at the operating company, with the required notice and consent for employer‑owned life insurance.

Who it's for

A captive makes sense for a business that is consistently profitable, has a meaningful and identifiable set of risks that are uninsured, underinsured, or overpriced in the commercial market, has strong loss control and good claims history, and is willing to operate the captive as a real insurer: actuarial pricing, regulatory filings, a captive manager, audited financials, claims handling, and annual costs that can run well into five or six figures. Owners need a long horizon, because the economics depend on years of disciplined underwriting.

It is not for a business looking primarily for a tax deduction, one without genuine risks to insure, one too small to justify the operating cost, or an owner who would want ready access to the captive's capital.

When / why the problem actually shows up

The need surfaces when commercial insurance stops fitting. A carrier raises premiums sharply after a market‑wide event, not the company's own losses. A renewal arrives with new exclusions for cyber or supply chain risk. A business discovers that a risk that could shut it down, such as loss of a major customer, regulatory change, or a product recall, is uninsurable at any reasonable price. A company with an excellent safety record is subsidizing worse risks through commercial rates. It also surfaces, less helpfully, when a business owner hears about captives as a tax strategy, and that is the moment a careful review is most needed.

How it's structured

  1. The operating company pays premiums to the captive for specific policies and deducts them if the arrangement is insurance.
  2. The captive is licensed in a domicile (a U.S. state or an offshore jurisdiction that regulates captives), capitalized, managed by a captive manager, priced by an independent actuary, and audited.
  3. Risk distribution is achieved by insuring enough independent risks, often through participation in a risk pool with unrelated businesses or by insuring multiple affiliated companies.
  4. The owners own the captive, directly or through trusts. Ownership affects estate planning, the 831(b) diversification requirements, and succession.

The flow: premiums go to the captive; claims are paid from the captive under its policies; reserves are invested conservatively; underwriting profit, if any, accumulates in the captive and is taxed according to its election. Over the long term, value may be returned to owners through dividends or liquidation, which are taxable events and must be planned carefully. Life insurance, where it belongs, sits outside the captive's reserves: in an irrevocable trust for estate liquidity, in a buy‑sell structure for owners, or with the operating company for key person protection.

Red flags — what to look for

The first list is signals that a captive may genuinely fit. The second is signals of an arrangement that needs immediate review.

Signals of a potential fit: - Commercial premiums rising with no change in claims history. A business with an excellent loss record paying more every year because of market conditions. - Large deductibles or self‑insured retentions. The company is already retaining significant risk informally, without reserves or structure. - Exclusions for the risks that matter most. Cyber, supply chain, warranty, or regulatory exposures that are excluded or capped far below the real exposure. - Multiple related businesses. Several affiliated operating companies with distinct risks can improve risk distribution.

Signals that an existing arrangement needs review: - The captive almost never pays claims. A very low loss ratio over many years is a regulatory flag under the 2025 regulations. - Premiums that track the tax benefit. Premiums set close to the 831(b) limit each year regardless of the underlying risk. - Captive money flowing back to the owners. Loans, guarantees, or other transfers from the captive to the insured company, its owners, or related parties. - Life insurance owned by the captive on the owners. Reserves invested in policies benefiting the owners rather than held to pay claims. - No recent Form 8886 conversation. An existing micro‑captive whose owners are unsure whether disclosure has been considered under the 2025 regulations.

Common pitfalls

  • Starting with the tax deduction. A captive designed around the 831(b) benefit rather than around real risk is the pattern the IRS has litigated and regulated. The risk analysis must come first, and the tax result must follow from it.
  • Pricing premiums to a target. Premiums must come from an independent actuarial analysis of the actual risks. Premiums set to absorb a target amount of taxable income invite challenge.
  • Weak risk distribution. A captive that insures only one company's limited risks, or relies on a pool that does not genuinely distribute risk, may fail the insurance tests.
  • Using captive capital as a personal or business bank. Loans, guarantees, and similar transfers back to the insured or its owners are a central element of the listed transaction definition.
  • Putting life insurance on the owners inside the captive. It weakens the captive's standing as a real insurer and can look like a disguised return of capital. Address owner life insurance needs outside the captive.
  • Ignoring disclosure. Failure to disclose a listed transaction or a transaction of interest carries significant penalties for participants and, potentially, advisors. Existing captives should be reviewed against the 2025 regulations with tax counsel.
  • Forgetting estate and succession planning. A valuable captive is an estate asset with its own transfer and liquidity issues. Ownership, buy‑sell provisions, and liquidity should be planned alongside the operating company.

Client example

This is a composite, illustrative example, not a specific client.

The client. Two brothers, ages 58 and 54, owned a regional distribution company with about $60M in revenue and an excellent safety and claims record. Their commercial premiums had risen steadily for three years despite few claims, and their renewal added a cyber exclusion and a much lower supply chain interruption limit, just as their operations became more dependent on both. A previous advisor had suggested a micro‑captive "to save taxes," and their CPA was skeptical.

The trigger. The renewal made the coverage problem concrete, and the CPA wanted an independent look before anything was formed. The brothers also had an open question their estate attorney had raised: their buy‑sell agreement covered the operating company, but nothing addressed what would happen to any new entity they created.

The structure. The CPA engaged an independent captive manager and actuary, with tax counsel reviewing the design. The feasibility study identified specific underinsured risks (cyber, supply chain interruption, and product warranty) and priced them independently. The resulting captive was capitalized, domiciled in a regulated U.S. jurisdiction, and participated in a risk‑distribution arrangement; premiums were set by the actuary, not by a tax target. Reserves were invested conservatively, with no loans or transfers back to the operating company or the brothers. The strategist's role was at the owner level: the buy‑sell agreement was updated to cover ownership of the captive along with the operating company, the cross‑purchase funding was reviewed and increased to reflect the combined value, and each brother's estate plan was revised to address the captive interest.

The outcome. The company now has coverage for risks the commercial market was excluding, priced to its own loss experience, under a structure built to stand on insurance substance rather than tax motivation. Ownership transitions for both entities are covered by a funded buy‑sell. Whether the captive produces underwriting profit depends entirely on future claims, and the brothers understand that the captive must operate as an insurer, with real claims, real reserves, and ongoing compliance, for as long as it exists.

The advisor angle

Captives are one of the areas where an advisor's skepticism is most valuable. Many business owners first hear about them as a tax strategy, and that framing is the one most likely to lead to trouble. The useful conversation starts with risk: what the business is not insuring well, what it is overpaying for, and whether it has the scale and discipline to run an insurer.

A legitimate captive needs a captive manager, an actuary, tax counsel, the CPA, and the estate attorney, each with a distinct role, and none of those roles should be filled by someone whose compensation depends on the captive being formed. The part that is most often overlooked is the owner level: how the captive's ownership fits the buy‑sell, the estate plan, and the family's liquidity. Keeping life insurance in that role, and out of the captive's reserves, protects both the client and the advisors involved.

Let's talk

Have a client who may benefit?

Bring the situation — we'll pressure‑test the fit and the structure together. New to working with Josh? Start with an Introduction.

To be clear, this isn't a product pitch. Captive design belongs with a captive manager, an actuary, and tax counsel; my role is the ownership, succession, and liquidity planning around it. If that's where your client needs help, we'll build it together. If it isn't, you'll walk away sharper.