When a Partner Leaves AliveFunding the Rest of the Buy‑Sell
A strategy for co‑owners whose buy‑sell agreement is funded for death but not for the exits that are far more likely to happen first (retirement, disability, a voluntary departure): coordinating disability buyout coverage, permanent policies whose cash value builds a buyout reserve, and agreement terms that keep the price, the funding, and the post‑Connelly tax picture aligned for every trigger, not just one.
Owners of closely held businesses with a buy‑sell agreement already in place, often already insured for death, whose agreement also promises to buy out an owner who becomes disabled, retires, or simply wants out, with no money set aside for those events.
A buy‑sell that can actually be performed whichever exit comes first, with funding matched to each trigger, a price that stays current, and an entity structure that accounts for how insurance proceeds now affect the value of the business.
This agreement says the company buys out a partner who retires or becomes disabled. Where does that money come from, and has anyone checked whether the structure still works after Connelly?
Watch first
The full picture
What it is
Most conversations about funding a buy‑sell agreement focus on death, and for good reason: life insurance solves the death trigger cleanly and is the subject of the companion entry on that topic (Strategy #9). But a typical buy‑sell is triggered by much more than death. It usually obligates, or gives an option, to buy an owner's interest at disability, retirement, voluntary departure, termination, divorce, or bankruptcy. For owners in their 40s and 50s, several of those events are more likely than death to happen first. And unlike death, they come with no insurance check attached.
When a living trigger arrives unfunded, the agreement usually falls back on an installment note: the company or the remaining owners pay the departing owner over five to ten years out of future profits. That turns the departing owner into a long‑term creditor of a business they no longer control, strains the company's cash flow just as it adjusts to losing a principal, and creates exactly the tension buy‑sell agreements are meant to prevent. In a disability, it is worse: the business is paying a buyout and possibly salary continuation while also replacing the disabled owner's work.
Funding the living triggers uses a different set of tools:
- Disability buyout insurance. A specialized disability policy, owned by the business or the co‑owners, that pays a lump sum (or a down payment plus installments) to fund the purchase of a disabled owner's interest after an elimination period that is often 12 to 24 months. It requires a definition of disability in the agreement that matches the policy's definition, a waiting period that matches the elimination period, and coverage amounts carriers will support, which are often capped relative to the business's value.
- Permanent life insurance cash value as a buyout reserve. In a cross‑purchase or entity‑owned design using permanent coverage, the cash value accumulates over the owners' working years. At a retirement or departure, that cash value can be accessed through withdrawals or policy loans to fund a down payment or the full buyout, or a policy can be transferred as part of the purchase price. This turns the same policies that fund the death trigger into a sinking fund for the living triggers.
- A deliberate sinking fund or installment design. For whatever insurance cannot cover, a planned reserve in the business and installment terms that are realistic for the company's cash flow, with security for the departing owner.
The second half of the strategy is keeping the agreement itself current. The price formula, the valuation date, and the payment terms determine whether a living buyout goes smoothly. And since June 2024, the entity structure needs a fresh look. In Connelly v. United States, the Supreme Court unanimously held that life insurance proceeds received by a corporation to fund a redemption are a corporate asset for estate tax valuation, and that the redemption obligation does not offset them. For owners using an entity‑owned (redemption) design, a deceased owner's shares can be valued higher for estate tax than the agreement price, while the family receives only the agreement price. That is a reason to revisit many existing agreements, and to consider cross‑purchase or insurance LLC designs, which keep the proceeds outside the company.
Who it's for
The best fit is two to five owners of an operating business with a buy‑sell agreement already drafted, often already funded for death, usually with owners in their 40s to early 60s. The business is valuable enough that a buyout is real money: a $3M, $15M, or $40M company. These owners are working in the business, so disability is a meaningful risk, and they have different timelines for retirement. Age gaps among owners are common and important: the oldest owner's retirement buyout is often the first trigger the agreement will face. Companies using an entity‑owned redemption structure for their life insurance, especially C corporations, are a priority after Connelly.
When / why the problem actually shows up
The issue tends to surface when a living exit becomes imaginable. The senior owner mentions retiring in five years, and the junior owners realize they have no idea how they would pay. One owner has a serious illness or injury and is out for months, and everyone reads the disability clause for the first time. An owner's divorce raises the question of whether the business must buy back shares awarded to a spouse. A lender's renewal asks about succession. An attorney updating the agreement after Connelly notices that the funding only covers death. Or the agreement's fixed price, set years ago and never updated, is wildly out of line with the current value, and one owner wants out at the old number while the others want the new one. The trigger is the moment the agreement has to be performed by people who are still alive.
How it's structured
The planning pass covers four pieces:
- Map every trigger. List each event the agreement names, whether it is mandatory or optional, who buys, at what price, and on what payment terms. Most agreements reveal at least one trigger with no funding and unrealistic terms.
- Match funding to each trigger. Life insurance for death (structured as in Strategy #9). Disability buyout coverage for disability, with the agreement's definition, waiting period, and payment terms aligned to the policy. Permanent policy cash value, a sinking fund, or both for retirement and departure, sized to the most likely first trigger (often the oldest owner's retirement). Realistic installment terms with security for whatever remains.
- Revisit the structure after Connelly. For entity‑owned designs, evaluate the estate‑tax effect of company‑received proceeds on each owner's shares. Alternatives include a cross‑purchase (owners hold policies on each other), an insurance LLC or partnership that owns the policies for several owners, or a hybrid design; each has its own transfer‑for‑value and administration considerations, and changes to existing policies must be handled carefully to avoid a transfer‑for‑value problem.
- Keep the price and terms current. Replace stale fixed prices with a formula or an appraisal process, set a regular review (often every two to three years), and align coverage amounts with the value as the business grows.
The money flows differently for each trigger. At death, the carrier pays the policyowner, who buys the deceased owner's interest. At disability, after the elimination period, the disability buyout policy pays the owner of that policy, which funds the purchase. At retirement or departure, the policyowners access cash value or the company draws on its reserve to fund the down payment, with any balance paid under the installment terms. For every trigger, the agreement names the price and the funding is already there.
Red flags — what to look for
These are the signals in a real client situation that the living triggers of a buy‑sell need funding attention.
- A buy‑sell funded with term insurance only. Death is covered; retirement, disability, and departure have no funding at all.
- An owner who talks about retiring within ten years. The first trigger the agreement will face is likely a living one, and the buyers have no plan for paying it.
- A disability clause nobody has read. The agreement defines disability, or doesn't, with no matching insurance and no realistic payment terms.
- An entity‑owned redemption design, especially in a C corporation. After Connelly, the company's receipt of proceeds may increase each owner's estate‑tax value. The structure needs review.
- A fixed price set years ago. The agreement names a dollar value or a formula nobody has updated, creating a built‑in dispute at the first living exit.
- A wide age spread among owners. The oldest owner's retirement will arrive long before the others', and the buyers need a funding plan sized to that date.
- Installment terms that assume a healthy company. A payout schedule that only works if the business performs as well after the departing owner leaves as before.
Common pitfalls
- Treating "funded" as meaning "funded for death." The most common hole in buy‑sell planning. Every trigger the agreement names needs a funding answer, even if the answer is a well‑designed installment note.
- Mismatched disability definitions. If the agreement's definition of disability, or its waiting period, differs from the disability buyout policy's, the agreement can require a purchase the policy does not fund. Draft the two together.
- Leaving entity‑owned designs unexamined after Connelly. Proceeds received by the company can raise the estate‑tax value of a deceased owner's shares above the agreement price. Owners should understand the effect and consider whether a cross‑purchase or insurance LLC is a better fit.
- Restructuring policies carelessly. Moving existing policies from the company to the owners, or among owners, can trigger the transfer‑for‑value rule and make the death benefit partly taxable. Use a recognized exception and get advice before any policy changes hands.
- Overcounting cash value. Policy illustrations project cash value, they do not guarantee it, and loans and withdrawals reduce the death benefit. Size the retirement reserve conservatively and confirm the death trigger remains funded after any access.
- Stale valuations. A price that was fair when the agreement was signed can become unfair in either direction. Build in a formula or periodic appraisal, and review coverage when the value moves.
Client example
The client. Three co‑owners of a commercial printing and packaging company valued at about $15M: the founder, 63, owning 50%, and two partners, 48 and 45, owning 25% each. Their buy‑sell agreement, drafted twelve years earlier, called for the company to redeem an owner's shares at death, disability, or retirement at a fixed price. The company owned term policies on each owner for death.
The trigger. The founder told his partners he planned to retire within four years. Their attorney, asked how the retirement buyout would work, read the agreement closely: the fixed price was less than half of current value, the disability clause had no definition and no funding, and the entity‑owned redemption design raised the estate‑tax issue the Supreme Court had addressed in Connelly. The retirement buyout had no funding at all. The attorney brought us in, working alongside the company's CPA, to design the funding while she redrafted the agreement.
The structure. The attorney replaced the fixed price with an independent appraisal at each triggering event and defined disability to match the coverage we placed. We helped the owners move to an insurance LLC that owns the life policies on all three owners for a cross‑purchase design, structured to fit within transfer‑for‑value exceptions with the attorney and CPA, which keeps the death proceeds outside the company and avoids the Connelly valuation effect. The two younger partners' coverage was placed in permanent policies whose cash value is designed to build a reserve for their own future retirements. For the founder's retirement in four years, the company and the two partners agreed to a down payment from a dedicated sinking fund the company began building immediately, with the balance paid over seven years under a secured note. Disability buyout coverage was placed on the two younger owners; the founder's age and the short horizon made it impractical for him, so the agreement uses installment terms for his disability trigger.
The outcome. The founder now knows how and when he will be paid, at a current value. The two younger partners have a funded plan for the founder's retirement, a death trigger funded outside the company, disability buyout coverage on each other, and a cash‑value reserve building toward their own exits years from now. The family of any owner who dies receives the appraised value without the company's receipt of proceeds inflating the estate tax on the shares. The attorney's careful reading of a twelve‑year‑old document turned a buy‑sell that only worked at death into one that works for every exit it names.
The advisor angle
Buy‑sell agreements tend to be reviewed when someone dies, and that is the trigger they are best prepared for. The exits that come first, a retirement or a disability, are often the ones nobody has funded. Attorneys and CPAs see the signals in the documents: term‑only funding, a fixed price from years ago, a disability clause with no definition, an entity‑owned design that predates Connelly. Raising the living triggers is not a criticism of the original agreement; it is the next layer of planning that the agreement's own terms call for.
The specialized work is in matching funding to each trigger, aligning disability definitions with coverage, building a cash‑value reserve that does not undermine the death funding, and restructuring ownership after Connelly without creating a transfer‑for‑value problem. That is the advanced planning Unified Advice brings to the client's existing team, with the agreement itself staying in the attorney's hands.
Strategy descriptions are educational and general in nature. Tax, legal and estate outcomes depend on how a strategy is structured and on each client's own facts; the results described here assume the strategy is properly structured and applicable requirements are met. Confirm current law and individual circumstances before acting.
Have a client who may benefit?
Bring the situation — we'll pressure‑test the fit and the structure together. New to working with Josh? Start with an Introduction.
And to be clear, this isn't a product pitch. It's how I help advisors make sure the agreement their clients signed can actually be carried out. If it's a fit, we'll build it together. If it's not, you'll walk away sharper.