The Strategy Library
Strategy No. 07

Keeping Key People Without Giving Up EquityThe Section 162 Executive Bonus

A strategy for business owners who need to reward and retain a few essential people but won't give up equity and don't want the complexity of a deferred compensation plan: the company pays a deductible bonus that funds a permanent life insurance policy the executive owns, optionally with a restrictive endorsement that ties the policy's value to staying with the company.

Executive BenefitsBusiness & Succession
Last reviewed: October 2026
Who It's For

Closely held businesses with a handful of key employees, or owner‑employees themselves, who want a meaningful, selective benefit beyond the qualified plan without equity dilution or plan administration.

Key Benefit

A current tax deduction for the company, a portable asset with death benefit and cash value for the executive, and, through a restrictive endorsement, a retention hook the owner controls.

Trigger Question

If this client's best operator got a better offer tomorrow, what would they be walking away from?

Watch first

Instructional video
Josh Sterling teaches this strategy
In this walkthrough, Josh teaches the executive bonus arrangement end to end: how the bonus is deducted and taxed, why a "double bonus" that covers the executive's tax changes how the benefit feels, how a restrictive endorsement turns a simple bonus into a retention tool, when an owner‑employee should use it for themselves, and how it compares with deferred compensation and split‑dollar so you can tell which one a client actually needs.

The full picture

What it is

Closely held businesses often depend on a few people the owner cannot afford to lose: a chief operating officer who runs the shop floor, a sales leader who carries the biggest relationships, a controller who knows where everything is. Retaining them is a real business problem. Raises are permanent and visible. Equity dilutes ownership, complicates a future sale, and brings minority‑holder rights. Qualified retirement plans must cover employees broadly and have contribution limits. A nonqualified deferred compensation plan can be the right answer, but it adds documentation, Section 409A compliance, and a liability on the company's balance sheet. Many owners want something simpler that still feels substantial to the person receiving it.

A Section 162 executive bonus is that simpler tool. The company pays a bonus to a selected executive, and the bonus is used to pay the premium on a permanent life insurance policy that the executive owns. Under Section 162, the bonus is deductible to the business as compensation, provided total compensation is reasonable. The executive includes the bonus in taxable income as W‑2 wages. Many companies pay a double bonus, an additional cash amount that covers the executive's income tax on the premium bonus, so the benefit costs the executive nothing out of pocket.

What the executive receives is real property: a policy they own, with a death benefit for their family and cash value that can grow and, in a policy designed for it, be accessed later through withdrawals and loans to supplement retirement income. Because the executive owns the policy, it is portable. That portability is the plan's strength for recruiting and its weakness for retention, which is why the restrictive endorsement exists.

A restricted executive bonus arrangement (REBA) adds two pieces: a separate agreement between the company and the executive, and an endorsement on the policy that prevents the executive from surrendering it, borrowing against it, withdrawing value, or changing ownership without the company's consent. The restriction typically lifts at a specified date or vesting schedule, at retirement, or at death. If the executive leaves early, the agreement can require repayment of some or all of the bonuses. The company keeps its deduction; the executive gets a growing benefit they cannot fully use until they have stayed.

Who it's for

The best fit is a profitable closely held company, often S corporations, partnerships, or C corporations with tens of millions in revenue, with two to ten people the owner considers essential. The owner wants to choose who participates, which a qualified plan does not allow, and wants the cost to be a current deduction. The executives are typically in their 30s to 50s, well compensated, and either already maxing their 401(k) or likely to value permanent coverage for their families. The arrangement also works for owner‑employees: an owner of a C corporation can bonus themselves a premium and take a deduction for a policy they own personally, often as a building block for estate or retirement planning. It is a weaker fit where the company wants to recover its outlay (split‑dollar does that), where the benefit should be a defined retirement promise (deferred compensation does that), or where the key person's departure would damage the business so badly that the company itself needs coverage (key person insurance does that).

When / why the problem actually shows up

The need surfaces at moments of retention risk or recognition. A key employee receives a competing offer, or the owner hears that a recruiter has been calling. The owner is planning for a sale or succession in five to ten years and needs the leadership team to stay through it. A strong year produces profits the owner wants to share with the people who produced them without creating a permanent raise. An owner considers granting equity, and the attorney or CPA raises the complications. An executive has asked about retirement benefits beyond the 401(k), whose 2026 elective deferral limit is $24,500, and the owner wants to respond. Or the owner simply realizes that their own business continuity depends on two or three people with no reason to stay beyond salary. The trigger is the owner's recognition that keeping a person is worth paying for, as long as the payment is simple and deductible.

How it's structured

The parties and the flow:

  1. The company selects participants, signs a bonus agreement (and, for a REBA, a restrictive endorsement agreement), and pays the premium bonus, plus any double bonus for taxes.
  2. The executive applies for and owns the policy, names their own beneficiaries, and includes the bonus in W‑2 wages.
  3. The insurance carrier issues the policy, typically permanent coverage designed for cash value accumulation, and records any restrictive endorsement.

Each year, the company pays the premium directly to the carrier (or pays it to the executive, who pays the carrier) and treats it as compensation. The company deducts it; the executive pays tax on it, often covered by the double bonus. During employment, the cash value grows inside the executive's policy. Under a REBA, the executive's access is limited until the vesting date or retirement. At retirement, the executive can take tax‑free withdrawals up to basis and policy loans from a properly designed, non‑MEC policy to supplement income. At the executive's death, their family receives the death benefit, generally free of income tax.

Plan design choices include who participates, the premium amount for each person, whether to double bonus, the vesting schedule, the repayment terms on early departure, and the policy design (death benefit oriented or cash value oriented). These should be documented in a written plan and coordinated with the company's other compensation so total compensation remains reasonable.

Red flags — what to look for

These are the signals in a real client situation that an executive bonus arrangement may genuinely fit.

  • An owner who names the same two or three people whenever the business comes up. The operator, the rainmaker, the person who "really runs the place."
  • A recent competing offer or a recruiter call. The retention risk has become visible and the owner is looking for something to put on the table.
  • An owner reluctant to grant equity. They have considered phantom stock or real equity and are uneasy about dilution, valuation, or a future buyer.
  • Executives already maxing their 401(k). Highly paid people who have hit the qualified plan limits and are looking for more.
  • A sale or succession planned within the next decade. The leadership team needs to stay through the transition, and the buyer will value continuity.
  • A strong year with no plan for sharing it. Profits the owner would like to share selectively without a permanent salary increase.
  • An owner‑employee of a C corporation with no personal permanent coverage. The owner could bonus the premium to themselves, deduct it, and own the policy personally.

Common pitfalls

  • Promising a retention tool without a restriction. A plain executive bonus gives the executive full control of the policy from day one. If retention is the goal, the plan needs a restrictive endorsement and a written agreement, or the executive can leave with the full benefit.
  • Ignoring reasonable compensation. The deduction depends on total compensation being reasonable. Large bonuses to owner‑employees, especially in C corporations, deserve a reasonableness review.
  • Overpromising the retirement income. Illustrations of future policy loans are projections, not guarantees. Design the policy conservatively, avoid MEC status if access during life is the goal, and set realistic expectations with the executive.
  • Forgetting the executive's tax. Without a double bonus, the executive pays income tax on the premium every year for a benefit they cannot spend. Some executives come to resent that, which defeats the purpose.
  • Using a bonus where the company should own the coverage. If the company would be badly damaged by a person's death, the company needs key person coverage it owns. A bonus plan protects the executive's family, not the business.
  • Drifting into deferred compensation. Adding promises of future payments, or tying the bonus to future events, can turn the arrangement into nonqualified deferred compensation subject to Section 409A. Keep the design clean, or build a deferred compensation plan deliberately.

Client example

The client. A 54‑year‑old owner of a commercial HVAC contractor with about $30M in revenue and 120 employees. Her chief operating officer and her head of estimating were, in her words, the two people the business could not run without. Both were in their 40s, both maxed their 401(k), and both had been approached by a larger competitor in the past year.

The trigger. She was planning to sell the company or transition it to the leadership team within seven to ten years and knew that any buyer would value those two people highly. She did not want to grant equity before a sale, and her attorney had cautioned her about phantom stock complexity. Her CPA brought us in to look at options that would be deductible, selective, and simple to administer.

The structure. Working with her CPA and attorney, we helped the company adopt a restricted executive bonus arrangement for both executives. The company bonuses each executive a fixed annual premium for a cash‑value‑oriented permanent policy the executive owns, plus a second bonus to cover the executive's income tax on it. A restrictive endorsement limits loans, withdrawals, and surrender without the company's consent until the executive completes eight years of service or turns 60, with partial repayment of bonuses required if they leave before then. The company deducts the bonuses as compensation; the CPA confirmed total compensation remained reasonable.

The outcome. Each executive now owns a policy that protects their family immediately and is designed to supplement their retirement income later, at no out‑of‑pocket cost to them. The owner has a deductible, selective benefit and a clear reason for her two most important people to stay through the transition, without giving up a share of the company. When a sale comes, the buyer inherits a leadership team with an incentive to remain. The CPA's question, what would keep these two people here, produced a plan the owner could explain in one conversation.

The advisor angle

The executive bonus is one of the simpler tools in executive benefits, and that simplicity is part of its value. Owners frequently face the retention question with only three familiar answers in view: raises, equity, or nothing. CPAs and attorneys often hear the concern first, during a tax projection, a compensation discussion, or a succession conversation, and the bonus arrangement belongs on the list alongside deferred compensation and split‑dollar.

The specialized work is in choosing correctly among those tools for each owner, and then designing the policy, the restriction, the vesting schedule, and the double bonus so the plan does what the owner intends. That is the advanced planning Unified Advice brings to the client's existing team, with the compensation and tax advice staying with the advisors who already handle it.

Let's talk

Have a client who may benefit?

Bring the situation — we'll pressure‑test the fit and the structure together. New to working with Josh? Start with an Introduction.

And to be clear, this isn't a product pitch. It's how I help advisors give business owners a simple, deductible way to keep the people who matter most. If it's a fit, we'll build it together. If it's not, you'll walk away sharper.