Giving to Charity Without Disinheriting the FamilyThe CRT and Wealth Replacement
A strategy for charitably minded clients holding a highly appreciated asset: a charitable remainder trust (CRT) sells the asset without immediate capital gains tax, pays the client an income stream for life or a term of years, and leaves the remainder to charity, while a life insurance policy held in a separate irrevocable trust replaces, for the children, the value the charity will eventually receive.
Clients with a large, low‑basis asset (real estate, a business interest, concentrated stock) who want income from it, have genuine charitable intent, and hesitate because a charitable gift would come out of what the children inherit.
A tax‑efficient sale and diversification of the asset, a lifetime income stream, a charitable deduction, and a gift to charity, with the family's inheritance replaced by an income‑tax‑free death benefit held outside the estate.
This client wants to sell an asset with an enormous built‑in gain and would like to support a cause. What's stopping them, the tax or the worry about what's left for the kids?
Watch first
The full picture
What it is
A client who owns a building bought decades ago, a business interest, or a block of stock with a basis near zero faces a familiar bind. Selling it triggers a large capital gains tax, often federal tax plus the 3.8% net investment income tax plus state tax, and reduces the capital available to reinvest. Keeping it leaves the family concentrated in one asset that may produce little income. Many of these clients also want to support a cause, but a charitable gift of the asset feels like taking it away from their children.
A charitable remainder trust is an irrevocable, tax‑exempt trust governed by Section 664. The client contributes the appreciated asset to the CRT. Because the trust is tax‑exempt, it can sell the asset without paying capital gains tax at the trust level and reinvest the full proceeds. The trust then pays the client (and often a spouse) an annual amount for life or for a term of up to 20 years. When the payments end, whatever remains goes to one or more charities the client chooses, which can include a family donor‑advised fund or private foundation, subject to the deduction rules for each.
The client also receives an income tax charitable deduction in the year of the gift, equal to the present value of the charity's remainder interest, calculated using the IRS Section 7520 rate, the payout rate, and the beneficiaries' ages or the term. The tax on the original gain is not eliminated; it is spread over time, because the annual payments carry out the trust's income under a tiering system (ordinary income first, then capital gains, then tax‑exempt income, then return of principal).
Two forms dominate:
- Charitable remainder annuity trust (CRAT). Pays a fixed dollar amount each year, between 5% and 50% of the initial value. No additional contributions are allowed. The charity's remainder must be worth at least 10% of the initial value, and a CRAT must also satisfy the IRS probability‑of‑exhaustion test or include the safe‑harbor provision the IRS published in 2016.
- Charitable remainder unitrust (CRUT). Pays a fixed percentage (between 5% and 50%) of the trust's value, revalued each year, so payments rise and fall with the portfolio. Additional contributions are allowed. Variations such as a net‑income‑with‑makeup unitrust (NIMCRUT) or a "flip" unitrust suit illiquid assets like real estate that will take time to sell.
Both must leave the charity a remainder worth at least 10% of the initial contribution.
The structural cost of all this is plain: at the end of the trust, the asset goes to charity, not the family. Wealth replacement addresses that directly. Part of the income or tax savings the CRT produces is used to fund gifts to a separate irrevocable life insurance trust (ILIT), which buys a policy, often survivorship coverage for a couple, sized to roughly the value the children would otherwise have inherited. At death, the ILIT receives the death benefit outside the estate and generally income‑tax‑free. The charity receives the CRT remainder. The children receive the replacement.
One 2026 change affects the math: under the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, starting in 2026 itemized charitable deductions are reduced by a floor of 0.5% of adjusted gross income, and for taxpayers in the top bracket the tax benefit of itemized deductions is capped at 35%. The CRT still works; the deduction is simply worth a little less than it was, and the models need to reflect it.
Who it's for
The best fit is a client age 55 or older, with a single highly appreciated asset worth seven or eight figures, a need or desire for income in retirement, and a genuine charitable interest. They usually have children they intend to provide for, which is exactly why they hesitate. They often hold the asset because selling feels too expensive, not because they want to keep it: a rental building they are tired of managing, a business interest they are about to sell, stock from a former employer. They need to be insurable, or a couple with at least one insurable spouse, for the wealth replacement piece to work, though a CRT can still make sense without it. Clients in high‑tax states benefit most, because the gain avoided at the moment of sale is largest.
When / why the problem actually shows up
The issue surfaces when a sale is coming. A client gets an unsolicited offer for a building they have owned for thirty years. A business owner is preparing for a sale and the CPA's projection shows a seven‑figure capital gains bill. A retiree holds concentrated stock that produces almost no dividend and wants income. A client mentions, almost in passing, a long‑standing commitment to a university, a hospital, or a faith community, and says they would do more "if it weren't for the kids." An estate plan review shows a large charitable bequest at death, when the client could have used the charitable intent during life to diversify and create income. Timing matters: the asset must go into the CRT before a sale is legally committed. Once there is a binding agreement to sell, the gain can be attributed back to the client.
How it's structured
The parties and the flow:
- The client (the donor and income beneficiary) transfers the appreciated asset to the CRT and receives the annual payments for life, joint lives, or a term of years.
- The CRT and its trustee sell the asset, reinvest the full proceeds in a diversified portfolio, and make the required payments. The client can serve as trustee in many situations, though an independent trustee is often wiser for hard‑to‑value assets.
- The charity or charities receive the remainder when the trust ends.
- The ILIT (wealth replacement trust) receives annual gifts from the client and uses them to pay premiums on a policy owned by and payable to the ILIT, typically managed with Crummey withdrawal rights so the gifts can use annual exclusions.
- The children are the beneficiaries of the ILIT and receive the death benefit.
The money flows as follows. The asset moves into the CRT; the trust sells it without trust‑level capital gains tax; the client takes a charitable deduction in the year of the gift and receives payments for life; part of those payments, or the tax savings from the deduction, funds gifts to the ILIT; the ILIT pays the premiums. At the client's death (or the second death for a couple), the CRT ends and its remaining assets go to charity, while the ILIT collects the death benefit for the children, outside the estate.
Red flags — what to look for
These are the signals in a real client situation that a CRT with wealth replacement may genuinely fit.
- A large asset with a basis near zero and a sale on the horizon. A building, a business interest, or concentrated stock where the projected capital gains tax runs to seven figures.
- An asset producing little or no income. Raw land, low‑dividend stock, or a building the client wants to stop managing, held by someone who now wants retirement income.
- Charitable intent stated with a "but." The client says they would give more "if it weren't for the kids" or "once we know the family is taken care of."
- A large charitable bequest in the will. The client plans to give at death what could do more good, and create more income for them, if given during life through a CRT.
- A client who is insurable and still in their 50s to early 70s. Old enough to value lifetime income, young enough that replacement coverage is affordable.
- A sale negotiation that has not yet produced a binding agreement. The window for a CRT closes once the sale is legally committed.
- An existing CRT with no replacement plan. The family already gave the asset away and nobody addressed what the children lose.
Common pitfalls
- Contributing the asset after a sale is committed. If the asset is transferred to the CRT after a binding agreement to sell, the IRS can attribute the gain to the donor. Bring the CRT into the plan before letters of intent harden into contracts.
- Choosing a payout that fails the tests. A payout set too high, or beneficiaries too young, can push the charity's remainder below 10% or fail the CRAT exhaustion test. Run the numbers at the current Section 7520 rate before drafting.
- Funding a CRT with debt‑encumbered or problem assets. Mortgaged real estate, S corporation stock, and certain business interests can create unrelated business taxable income or disqualify the trust. These assets need special handling, and some should not go into a CRT at all.
- Putting the replacement policy in the wrong hands. If the client owns the replacement policy personally, the death benefit lands in the taxable estate. It belongs in a properly administered ILIT, with Crummey notices sent every year.
- Selling the deduction instead of the plan. The charitable deduction is real but is only one piece, and the 2026 floor and cap reduce its value for some clients. A CRT should be justified by the diversification, the income, and the charitable purpose, with the deduction as a benefit.
- Sizing the replacement on today's value only. If the asset would have grown, the children's "replacement" should be sized to a realistic future value, not the value at contribution, or the family ends up short.
Client example
The client. A widow, age 67, owned a commercial building she and her late husband bought in the 1980s, now worth about $6M with a basis of under $500,000. The building produced modest net rent and a lot of management headaches. She had two adult children and a long relationship with her alma mater's nursing school, and she wanted retirement income she did not have to manage.
The trigger. A buyer approached with an attractive offer. Her CPA projected the federal and state tax on the sale at well over $1.5M. She told her CPA she had always meant to "do something" for the nursing school but would not shortchange her children. The CPA brought us in before she signed a letter of intent.
The structure. Working with her estate attorney and CPA, we helped her transfer the building to a charitable remainder unitrust with a 5% payout before any sale agreement was signed. The trust then sold the building and reinvested the full proceeds in a diversified portfolio, with no capital gains tax due at the trust level. She received a charitable deduction in the year of the gift and an income stream projected to exceed the building's net rent. Part of that income funded annual gifts to a new ILIT, which purchased a $4M permanent policy on her life, sized to what her children would otherwise have inherited from the building after tax. The ILIT's trustee sends Crummey notices each year.
The outcome. She replaced a concentrated, management‑intensive asset with a diversified income stream, without paying capital gains tax up front. At her death, the CRT's remainder will fund a scholarship at the nursing school in her and her husband's names, and the ILIT will pay her children a death benefit outside her estate and generally free of income tax. Her charitable wish and her family's inheritance stopped competing with each other. The CPA's timing, raising the idea before a contract was signed, is what made it possible.
The advisor angle
The CRT conversation usually starts with a tax projection, which puts CPAs, attorneys, and wealth managers in the best position to see it first. What often keeps it from moving forward is the family question, not the tax one: clients who would happily support a cause stop at the thought of taking value from their children. Wealth replacement answers that objection directly, and it is the piece that is most often left out.
The specialized work is in the coordination: modeling the CRAT or CRUT against the current Section 7520 rate and the 2026 deduction rules, timing the contribution ahead of the sale, sizing the replacement coverage to a realistic future value, and building the ILIT funding calendar around the trust's payouts. That is the advanced planning Unified Advice brings to the client's existing team, delivered through The CORE Process™.
Strategy descriptions are educational and general in nature. Tax, legal and estate outcomes depend on how a strategy is structured and on each client's own facts; the results described here assume the strategy is properly structured and applicable requirements are met. Confirm current law and individual circumstances before acting.
Have a client who may benefit?
Bring the situation — we'll pressure‑test the fit and the structure together. New to working with Josh? Start with an Introduction.
And to be clear, this isn't a product pitch. It's how I help advisors give clients a way to be generous without choosing between charity and family. If it's a fit, we'll build it together. If it's not, you'll walk away sharper.